Best Game for Xbox Live...Help Needed
The misanthropic smartass in me says "Oblivion."
The common sense part of me, however small, says "Listen to the misanthropic smartass".
The 'If you must' guy says "Gears, for its options and the fact that it seems like they'll be supporting it with updates and DLC for at least another couple years." A lot of the quality online games so far just have very steep learning curves and/or their 'communities' intimidate novices, intentionally and through sheer superiority.
They all agree, though, that the best is yet to come concerning a 360 Live experience, and that doesn't necessarily mean Halo 3.
P.S. Do you 'defiant' headset-free types in Halo 2 find yourself getting kicked often for denying the assholes their source of power?
P.P.S. Listening to a very recent "Sports Anomaly" podcast (1up.com) the other day, and Bryan Intihar made a point of stating that his online sports game competition was considerably nicer than FPSes. That just seems like selective perception. Comments?