[quote name='DesertLeo']I had the hardest time getting into XIII, though lord knows as a (once) die-hard FF fan I tried to. I put about 10-12 hours into it, did I give up too soon?[/QUOTE]
My opinion, yes. The game opens up at ~20 hours giving you more to explore, a change of party option, new paradigm roles, and optional missions. Of course you'll hit another wall-block, which at that point just beat the game and you'll unlock another 20+ hours of optional content.
This game still has 80-90+ hours of content in it, which is more than 13-2 offers (40~60 hours total, much less if you skip optional stuff and post game stuff), so I can't wrap my head around all the complainers. Go play any action, platformer, FPS, etc and they are much more linear with less content. The downside is that obviously everyone gives up before it hits them, but if you stick with it the last 60 hours are very enjoyable, customizable, and what I remember of the game, fun.
Any true FF fan should remember FF7-FF10, and FF12. Each of those games are 60-120 hours. Why would you judge a game on 18% of its content. That's like saying FF7 was just the town of Midgard for the whole game, and it got boring.
FF7 sucks because it brought out all the sephiroth emos. Main character is a failed clone experiment, who cares, worse story. FF4 and FF6 are awesome and the best in the series still.
Edit: [quote name='Ecofreak']Just finished the game, clocking 50 hours. First main-line Final Fantasy game I've finished since X! I think this is a solid deal for anyone interested in trying out both games. [/quote] This is why I think they decided to make the game linear, because most people never finish any FF titles, like my little brother. He likes them, but never can finish them. This way everyone gets to experience the full story.