[quote name='joe2187']Alright alright i get it, i was hating.
Just interested in what its appeal is to people[/quote]
For the most part, at least in all the 'super anime fans' I've met, it's been that it's still new enough to be considered exotic/cool/whatever, and the repetitiveness of most of it is still excused by the fact it's 'Japanese'. (Bit of an over-generalization, but that's been my experience with most of them)
That said, as said before, it's pretty much subjective. Why might I prefer Bioshock over Mass Effect, while someone else would say the converse, despite the fact they both have shooting elements? It all boils down to personal taste.