[quote name='NoHo']$30 for a game that won't come with a case and manual and will probably be in such bad shape it won't even be playable.
Just spring the extra $10 and buy it new from an Independant retailer.[/quote]
Someone has large ideals and an even bigger pocketbook - this is cheapassgamer, not makeastandbypayingmoremoneygamer.
Have you ever actually ordered from them? And if you did, have you ever heard of returning an unsatisfactory purchase? Yes, there is a chance you will get something that doesn't meet your expectations, but you can return it. I've gotten probably 20 used games from gamestop.com over the last five years and every single one is as I expected or better. And If I ever do get one that is stripped and unplayable, you can be sure I'm getting my money back.
I just showed this to a friend who is a Gamefly member and he is going to take the dreaded Gamestop plunge instead, it saves him a couple more dollars.