[quote name='serum79']Wow!! What a freak! Do people actually care if game discs are loose in factory sealed products? That shouldn't affect how much they go for. I don't think the discs can get scratched or damaged in their cases if they're loose, there's barely enough room for them breathe.[/QUOTE]
Actually they do get damaged. When I bough Shadow of the Colossus I didn't notice that the disc inside was loose. I only noticed at home when I finally opened it. And there was a nice pair of scratches on the disc. It wasn't anything major that would mess up the gameplay but it still pissed me off the I paid for an already semi damaged product.
I think that the guy is truly a perfectionist like he says, asking for the registration insert is way too much for any normal person. But I still think that you should just try and make him happy, after all you do want his money.
And I will put my guess on the [font=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]Samba De Amigo. I would bid on it in a second if I had the money, it looks like such an awesome game and I have heard great things about it as well.
[/font]