[quote name='etschell']Don't know if this is a re-post but here it goes:
Prince of Persia: $24.99
Resistance 2: $37.99
Guitar Hero III: LOR $29.99
If you haven't order pre played from gamefly,
disks, cases and instruction manuals are flawless.[/QUOTE]
Every disk (of about 12 or so) I've ever gotten came with some chipped and nicked edges, only one ever broke but it did so inside my 360 (luckily most of the pieces stayed in the tray). However had that happened in my slot loading PS3 it would have meant shipping it to get serviced at the minimum.
If you plan on keeping these games for a while beware of the potential for laser-rot & breakage occurring from damaged coatings.
Don't hesitate if you are going to play and trade them quickly but, don't add these to your backlog.
(example above is a cracked blu-ray from netflix, but this is representative of exactly what I have gotten) The damage occurs from the USPS automated sorting/conveying machines and the paper thin packaging- during mailed transit.
tl;dr
In short just check them carefully when you get them, before you put them in your console or backlog.