[quote name='PublikDefender']Who is more reputable, Overstock deals or Newbury Comics?
(I don't like shady sellers that re-seal games etc. like Hitgaming)[/QUOTE]
I've never bought anything from Overstock, but I love Newbury Comics. We have a few of them in my area, and everything I've ever bought from them has been in perfect condition (both in-store and online). I may just have excellent luck with them, but they're very reputable in my experience.