[quote name='M1C13']All they are saying is that a hit like anything else takes your health down without the consideration of timing at all. So if I have lower health and get hit may lose all my health and die if I have more health then the person hitting me and don't die then hit back they will die.[/QUOTE]
No no no no no. You're not getting it. The melee does not take away the full amount of health possible for the player who has more health, even if the other technically swung first and the hit would have killed the guy with more health.
[quote name='M1C13']Your first statement doesn't make sense, if both people are hit it takes the same amount of health for both and if one persons health is low he dies, it doesn't take more health from one and less from the other that is the problem if it actually came down to timing.[/QUOTE]
Except for the fact that in Halo 3, "at the same time" actually means "both within a certain timing window". Even if both impacts occur at the same time, the one with more health wins.
[quote name='M1C13']And your second statement doesn't make sense either if the melee takes 18% and both people had less than that then yes the first person hit would die. Thats the way it works by how much health someone has.[/QUOTE]
Umm....do you even know what the change was, cause it seems like you have no idea. Let me repeat myself. again:
If both people swing "at the same time", the person with more health gets the kill and lives even if the impact from the other player would have killed him.
[quote name='M1C13']And keeping track of your health and taking cover when you need to is skill that is why they reward you for killing sprees, because you can stay alive. There isn't much skill in running up to someone and hoping you hit them first because the first to hit gets the kill, that would be ridiculous because if I have 100% health and you don't I would hope it doesn't come down to timing.[/QUOTE]
And avoiding getting shot as you're running up to swing and learning to use the melee effectively are not aspects of an overal Halo 3 skill set, right? Oh wait, of course they are.
[quote name='M1C13']EDIT: I'm sure if it wasn't the melee system it would be something else. everyone has there reason for not getting a kill or losing.[/QUOTE]
Ah, the "I have nothing else to add, so you suck" argument. Good job.