If they had just swapped the left analog stick and the digital pad (and given it a decent digital pad), all would have been well. They should have made it a bigger and better classic controller. They shouldn't have tried to make it similar, but not entirely like, the Gamecube controller. I really can't see what the point of that was if they weren't going to also make the button layout the same as the Gamecube controller (not that that would have been great, but going only half way is even worse). It's just weird. There's some good things in there, but really bad stuff too. Overall still a disaster.