[quote name='Vinny']Ico is still my favorite PS2 game. I love that game, more so than Shadow of the Colossus (I'm probably one of the few who prefer Ico over SotC). [/quote]
Add me to the list! Actually though, I didnt like SotC at all. I rented it and only fought the 1st colossus and realized that if this was what the game was, it wasnt going to be for me. IMO, SotC lacked the 'brain-teaser-lite' aspect of ICO, which is why I loved ICO.
I liked the 'concept' of SotC, and would still like to someday experience the story, but the gameply wasnt my cup 'o tea.