[quote name='charlescheese']Well since you don't like SotC you probably won't dig Ico. Secondly, you have bad taste. I'm sorry, I hate to be so blunt and to be the guy to break it to you, but yeah, you have bad taste.
I just played SotC and Ico for the first time earlier this year, and graphically Ico especially doesn't hold up all that well on an HDTV, but the game itself is awesome and oozes atmosphere. The puzzles are great, the gameplay is like no other. SotC similarly looks sub par on an HDTV, oozes atmosphere at every pore, and has gameplay like nothing else.
I guess what I'm saying is that maybe you should find a game with some generic bald space marines in it.
[/quote]
Because games with piss-poor frame rates, unresponsive controls and repetitive level design are only for those with refined tastes...
I liked SotC, but I wouldn't question anyone's taste for absolutely hating the game. The actual game is broken and a chore to play... The scope of the enemies and the atmosphere save the game but do not elevate it to masterpiece status.
As for Ico, I think it's better than its successor but almost entirely different. The controls are pretty similar, the frame rate (if I remember correctly) is more consistent, and the exploration is a little less sparse.