[quote name='sinkingships']the PS2 version is top quality.[/QUOTE]
[quote name='bigdaddybruce44']Logitech stuff is almost always of the highest quality. They are definitely a step above the average third-party. And they would seem to have a good relationship with Sony, considering they were the OEM on the official headset for the PS2.[/QUOTE]
I agree that Logitech makes good stuff, and the Cordless Precision/Cordless Action for PS2 were the best PS2 controllers I encountered, with all the functionality of the OEM plus wireless and arguably better ergonomics (at least if you have large hands). I didn't care for their floating D-pads, though.
This model, however, appears to lack OEM functionality: no tilt, incompatible rumble, non-native wireless requiring a dongle. I say "appears" because I don't own it; I'm going by reviews. I assume, however, if you preferred the ergonomics of the PS2 Logitechs then you'll find this offers the same advantage over the PS3 Dualshock.