[quote name='GaveUpTomorrow']Not even close. I played the demo and wasn't impressed at all. Graphically, the game is lacking. Gameplay wise, the game isn't very fun. Character wise, I don't like the designs at all. The controls felt very wonky as well. I like the overall feel of the world, but other than that I couldn't find anything else good to say about the game.
It says something when they start the game out for $59.99, then immediately drop the price to $39.99 upon release, and then have the game on sale for almost $20 upon release week. Maybe they just released a very poor demo compared to the rest of the game? But from what I've played, I wouldn't even waste a rental on this game. When Brotherhood is released in the same time period, not sure how anyone can vote this game of the year.[/QUOTE]
Just because you don't like a game (especially just based on the demo), doesn't mean it can't be somebody else's GOTY. Based on reviews, it's obvious that there are some people out there who really love the game. And the demo is only a small portion of the full game anyway, so I'm sure there's a lot more to the game than that.
And personally, I didn't like Assassin's Creed 2, but plenty of people called that their GOTY last year. It all comes down to personal taste. I'm not going to say that people were wrong for having it as their GOTY just because I didn't like it.