[quote name='shieryda']Does anyone have any of those fitness games for either 360 or Kinect? Looking to try one or 2 of them out, since I have a Kinect now. I don't run because I have shin splints something fierce, and don't want to pay a monthly gym membership. I have a couple 25 lb. dumbbells in the furnace room that I was using for a while. My wife does a couple crazy fitness dvds, but I feel like that's a bit too much for my lazy ass.
She has a jump-rope, too, that I should be using.[/QUOTE]
While I agree "getting out" is the best option, there are presently three possibilities on Kinect:
1. EA Sports Active 2
2. Your Shape: Fitness Evolved
3. The Biggest Loser: Ultimate Workout
1. EA Sports Active 2
This is an all-around decent workout, especially for the "new" base price of $19.99. (Original MSRP was $99.99!) Comes with a "heart monitor" that straps to your arm at the elbow. Heart monitor is in " " because it's only occasionally accurate and doesn't actually cover...y'know, your heart.
There are pre-set workouts and you can customize your workouts, and they will make you sweat. Oddly, a lot of exercises included in the Wii and PS3 versions are NOT present here and, having played the PS3 version as well, I couldn't think up a good reason why they weren't included in the 360 version.
Body tracking is hit-and-miss, with the biggest failings being anything on the ground - situps and pushups are poorly tracked. A promised patch never arrived and the game went on serious discount.
I played with this for about a month, before moving on to...
2. Your Shape: Fitness Evolved
I wanted to like this one. There's a lot to do, with exercises, mini-games, and even some (questionable) DLC.
Body tracking is on-par-with if not better than EA Sports Active 2 for the most part, but occasionally fails as well (certain yoga and tai-chi poses, for instance - even though I've done both for years and am quite good with my form, I could never appease the sensors in Your Shape). I found these exercises competent, but less enjoyable. But I can see how others may enjoy this one most of the three.
Which leads me to my personal favorite...
3. The Biggest Loser: Ultimate Workout (TBL)
To me, this is the best all-around package. The exercises and tracking are both very well done, with occasional hiccups on things like squats. Less irritating than EA Sports Active 2's inability to recognize a pushup, which actually won't progress the exercise if it doesn't recognize the required number of reps - so if you're supposed to do 10 pushups and it only recognizes 3, you have to either do 7 more and hope it picks them up or fool it into thinking you've done 7 more (note that both Your Shape and The Biggest Loser KEEP THE WORKOUT MOVING).
There are a lot of yoga-type exercises in the TBL routine and, as I'm partial to low-impact but high-focus workouts, this sits well with me.
The one caveat about TBL is the trainers. They repeat and repeat and repeat themselves often, perhaps moreso than the other two games. If you can tune them out for everything except what you need to hear, this may be your best bet.
CONCLUSION:
There are only three at present. An MMA training game is due at some point, but who knows when. Of the three, you can only download the demo for The Biggest Loser. Start there. If you like it, score, you're done.
If you don't like it or want to try the others, it's really a crap-shoot between Your Shape and EA Sports Active 2. All I can suggest is, if you go with Sports Active 2, buy it new (find it cheap), as you don't want a used arm-strap with someone else's sweat on it.
Frankly, it's a crap-shoot between all three titles. None of them exceeds the other two by leaps and bounds. Tracking is an issue on all three, but worst of all with EA Sports Active 2. If the tracking were solid, I'd give that a hearty recommendation. But it isn't. And I can't.
My personal favorite is The Biggest Loser. Second up would be Your Shape. And last, because of the tracking issues and limited exercises, Sports Active 2.
Anyway, hope this helps choose. Really looking forward to the MMA game - I do some boxing from time-to-time and an MMA training title would be so sweet (IF the tracking is solid). 'til then, we're left with three relatively interchangeable exercise titles - where personal preference will have the most say.