Although a good game, its definitely over hyped. Nowhere close to FFVI.Final Fantasy VII. Nothing can live up to the hype it was given.
This is a good one. BAT was getting crazy good reviews on release but it's so unplayable now. Only thing it's good for is the soundtrack. Infact most early 3D PS1 games are eyesores. They really don't stand the test of time like the 16-bit era could.That wasn't overrated. Everyone thought it sucked.
A true overrated game is Battle Arena Toshinden. It got high marks when it first came out. No one holds the series in high regard anymore.
I am not sure what some of you are using as criteria to determine if something is overrated but IMO it is this....
Any game that has fans that initially like a game and then the fans realized it was just a gimmick or poorly made is a real overrated game.