Yeah it's scary, but not so much as other horror games that have released in the past few years, including Amnesia. The puzzles are super dull and the pacing makes certain sections incredibly predictable. Just got to a new section, do a puzzle while sneaking around some super creepy dude, run from said dude, and eventually reach another area where you repeat the same cycle as above. If it puzzles were good, it'd be one thing, but they are all essentially fetch quests with crappy save points. I do love this game, but it definitely has plenty of faults.