[quote name='autopiloton']Second paragraph, first sentence.
But since you didn't get the implication, yes, I have.
But it's
not sharper and cleaner. It's blurry, grainy, and the colors look washed out. The upscaling makes the image look worse than it did on a standard definition television with s-video or component cables.
.[/QUOTE]
think you might be the one with those rose tinted glasses if you remember ps2 games looking anything but muddy, washed, out or grainy.
Just because you spent countless hours playing games on a backwards compatible system on a hdtv doesn't mean I should make an assumption that you have sat down and compared them back to back, and I still somehow doubt you actually did this.
Maybe its just my personal preference, but I think the games look significantly improved with scaling, and texture filtering. Clearly the unscaled version of the game looks significantly grainier in these screen shots comparing ff12 using the different filtering and scaling options. Furthermore, I don't see a loss in any kind of color saturation, only an improvement due to full screen antialiasing, and minor texture smoothing. Keep in mind these are all taken off a ps3, so it would actually look worse running through a ps2 with component. These are merely to show the difference with and without scaling and smoothing.
No scaling no texture smoothing
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa178/infernosoul1/normaloff.jpg
Full scaling, full texture smoothing
http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa178/infernosoul1/fullsmoothing.jpg
My argument was never that it was worthwhile to buy a used ps3 over a new one (whilst yours seems to be that there is no worthwhile improvement to having the scaler because no one should want to play ps2 games on a hdtv), my point was only that if you wanted to play your ps2 games on a HDTV they would look better with a 60gb than if you used a ps2. If you honestly think there is no improvement between those 2 images, then maybe you need to look into getting glasses.