(sorry guys, it's a really long one but it's the best score I've ever had)
I know I mentioned this to a couple of posters in the thread who had helped me out before but it's definitely time to get the word out in the open about this since I got my trade-ins done today and found out some values and am done with everything.
Basically, for those who haven't seen it, there's a thread about Hollywood Video/Movie Gallery and something else having all last gen games down to 3.99. There are 3 in town that aren't attached to Gamecrazy's (the ones attached to GC's are apparently not running the sale): Staples Mill north of Hungary in my neck of the woods, Mechanicsville, and one on a street called John Rolfe Parkway just south of Short Pump.
I ran into some initial resistance: the first place I went to (Staples Mill) said it was only for games 12.99 and under, one had to manually enter the 3.99 price (John Rolfe) but it was all worth it as I think all 3 stores were untouched when I first found them. Here's a post I made in the HV/MG thread about some of the issues I ran into during the initial stages of this sale:
http://www.cheapassgamer.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5074509&postcount=166
Ok, so here's the final tally from my trips to all 3 Hollywood Videos in the area. Oh, and a trip to the Movie Gallery around 4000 Broad that was mostly fruitless (picked up Sly Cooper as a hole filler since I never got the first one but they had maybe 2 shelves of stuff to 8+ for the HV's).
Also, the disclaimer: if you think this is hoarding, I apologize. I took no more than 1 of any game with a couple of exceptions (I took a pair of a couple of good flippers) and when I did, there was always at least 1 of that game left on the shelf. So there still should be some out there for people.
243.35 Spent
Kept the following for the personal collection:
Playstation 2
Marvel vs Capcom 2 - disc only
.hack (pt 3) Outbreak - complete!
.hack (pt 4) Quarantine - disc only
Suikoden III - missing instructions
Sly Cooper - missing instructions
Final Fantasy XI: Treasures of Aht Urghan - complete!
Yakuza - missing cover art
Magic Pengel - missing cover art
Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirit - disc only
Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver 2 - disc only
Tales of Legendia - disc only
Dark Cloud 2 - disc only
Wild Arms Alter Code: F - missing instructions
Unlimited Saga - disc only
Crimson Tears - complete!
GrimGrimoire - missing instructions
Metal Slug 4/5 - missing cover art
Gamecube
Super Mario Strikers - disc only
Lego Star Wars: Original Trilogy - missing cover art
Mario Party 4 - disc only
Simpson Hit and Run - disc only
XBox
Ninja Gaiden Black - complete!
Conker: Live and Reloaded - missing instructions; need XBox case
Mortal Kombat Deception - I think it's missing a bonus disc; need XBox case
The rest of these I might end up trading them or flipping them to GS/EB; on the fence about whether to keep them or not, so if anyone has opinions one way or another- to those who have played, any thoughts on which of these are worth keeping and playing?
All Playstation 2
Wild Arms 3 - scratch on disc only game, which I already had. D'oh
Arc the Lad: Twilight of the Spirit - D'oh, got a second copy
Metal Slug 4/5 - Also, d'oh, got a second copy
Phantasy Star Universe - disc only
Dynasty Warriors 3 - disc only
Dynasty Warriors 4 - disc only, scratch on top side of disc
Raiden III - missing cover art
Bloody Roar 4 - missing cover art
For bonuses, you could put this together with the "Trade 5+ games, get an extra 30% credit" at EB/GS. Here's the post I made about trade-in values after my trip to 3 store today:
http://www.cheapassgamer.com/forums/showpost.php?p=5089722&postcount=284
Traded in the rest to a couple of GS/EB for 375.54.
I went back to the one on Staples Mill today to see if I could bring a couple back (I stupidly spent $13 on Dark Cloud 2, thinking it was complete when it wasn't and a couple had pretty bad scratches on them). The guy there mentioned that someone came in and got over $300 worth of stuff so hopefully some of you guys in the area got some good deals before the ebayers and hoarders. There still should be some left out there, particularly at the Mechanicsville store unless someone went through and cleaned them out. Also, there's a chance they will pull some stuff from the rental pile and put it into the sale in the next few days, too- there are reports of that going on in the thread.
Looks like I have a day or two of printing out some suitable box art, scrounging up some better DVD cases, and maybe tracking down some instructions on ebay but this was easily my best sale of the year. Anyone know where to score some spare official cases, especially for Gamecube but also the green XBox and the PS2 cases with the memory card holders?
I'll be updating my trading thread shortly as well, either today or tomorrow. Anyone else who got in on this deal or has reports about the area stores, post 'em if you've got 'em. I'm definitely done- don't want to look good karma in the mouth here and I definitely want to be kind to fellow CAG'ers and let them in on the deal.
SI