[quote name='io']So I've never played this and have no idea what the crazy fanboy love for it is all about.[/QUOTE]
It's not a fanboy thing. It's just a very well written game, it's engaging, thoughtful, and touching without being saccharine. It's not that the mechanics or graphics are beyond everything else of its day, it's that the writing is so smart and funny.
Also, if you've played enough JRPGs to know the rigmarole, then EB is even better.
If you have every intention of buying it, you should know that it's illegal -- not to mention indecent and horrible of you -- to emulate it on a PC. That's a very bad idea.