It's ignorant and elitist to expect some wear and tear from used games? Especially from a rental service where the copy probably made it into the hands of quite a few people? Gamefly offers pretty good prices, probably with this in mind. If you aren't satisfied, there are plenty of other...
I would have bit on the 360/PS3 version of Goldeneye for a similar price.
I remember enjoying Cabella's African Safari, this new one seems to have gone all hardcore on me though.