I ask myself this question every year when my renewal time comes around, but I always end up letting it renew. I love the expedited shipping time, and I love not having to try to stack up 25 bucks worth of items to qualify for free shipping. As far as I'm concerned, that fee they charge is...
I do, for one.
Hell, I still have my Dreamcast and Saturn hooked up, sandwiched between my 360 and PS3.
And, on rare occasions, I even break out the Atari Flashback for a little Combat love. (The original 2600 is a bit of a pain to hook up with today's TVs)
Refurbished Microsoft XBOX 360's scare me. I bought two from Buy.com before. Both had the RROD within two days. Was able to send both of them back though after some arguing. I've heard similar stories from others. I don't trust any of these refurbished units.