I'm not surprised Gamestop was one of the nominees for this award. The deals they put up were ok during black friday but they only had a few that caught my eye. Most of them were door busters and I was unable to go to one anyway.
I was split between Steam and Amazon because Steam had that killer deal for about 15 or so THQ games for only 50$. But then again Amazon had the ps3 bundle with killzone 2 and infamous for 300$ and some other games that had significant price drops.
I voted Gamestop because after looking at the trade 2 games in and get a newly released game for 20$ I thought they contradicted themselves from "Power to the Players". It is good that their medicore trade in prices compelled other retailers to start a trade in program though.
I thought this was a no brainer simply due to the fact of amazon's performance during black Friday. They had very resonable prices and it was easy to find price drops through this site.