Same thing has happened to me. Ordered 6 games on May 1 and I'm still waiting on 2 of them to arrive. I'll be contacting them again today to either get them shipped finally or get a refund.
I still haven't received the second half of my order. UPS supposedly delivered the order to my local post office on the 15th and It still has not been delivered. The worst part is USPS is still saying pre-shipment. I guess I'm screwed at this point.
Gamestop has a weird definition of "shipped". The second half of my order has been "shipped" for the past 4 days, meanwhile the post office is still waiting to receive it. I swear this is the last time I order anything from GS.
Bought a "Mystery Bundle" on Fanatical and got nothing but Indie garbage. Let me know which game you want and I'll message it to you. If nobody wants any I'll just post them.
The Cat Lady
Still Not Dead
Asteroid Bounty Hunter
Frozen Synapse Prime
Super Cloudbuilt
Hungry Flame
Charlies...
Scribblenauts Unlimited - ENQHE-GM8P2-J7L?? (Stéphane Richer -> ??)
Bastion - ??KXP-Z7WGA-H4MW5 (Scarface, SW:Return of the Jedi, A Christmas Story all have this in common -> ??)
Pony Island
L4V9B-VT7H0-2QT8D
Company of Heroes 2 - Southern Fronts DLC
0T8I3-XZV0N-2YNVJ
Dawn of War II Retribution - Ultramarines DLC
532T9-29EXF-RH0F4