[quote name='tiktok0']As a long time Suikoden fan including trying to find all the backplots and constantly reading Suikosource/SARS for Suikoden speculation and what not...as well as a fan of strategy games...and having put 50+ hours into Suiko Tactics to get every single hidden piece and storyline...I will say Suiko Tactics deserves a low 5 out of 10, 50%, mediocre, what have you.
If it wasn't for the Suikoden name and the fact that it was supposed to clear up the holes in Suikoden 4 (which was also mediocre unfortunately), I would not recommend it. Putting 50+ hours in was a long stretch, as I am pretty sure I could have beat it in under 10, which is ridiculous for a strategy game.
The storyline is super easy to follow, almost no surprises, almost nothing worthwhile, and compared to other tactics games like Tactics Ogre, FF Tactics, or even Shining Force 2...this game was very lackluster in every department but especially in storyline.
Is it a bad game? No. It was playable. It had some optional characters I wanted to like a lot, but there was almost no storyline whatsoever with them. Of the 40 or so characters in the game, 25 of them are sword wielders that are all the exact same with different portraits, it just seemed like very little effort was put in. It is so unfortunate because the Suikoden series should and could easily be made into a strategy game that is incredible. The biggest problem is not the system it runs, but the lack of depth in story and effort. Try to find Suikoden 1/2/3 (maybe 5, haven't tried it), or go back to the old strategy games like Shining Force 2 or Tactics Ogre if you want a better fix.[/quote]
You did a nice mini-review.
I'm a fan of S-RPG so I'm disappointed that this Suikoden is so bad. Konami did some pretty good S-RPG in the past: Vandal Hearts 1&2.
I guess I'll keep waiting for FFT2 or at least VH3

.