[quote name='FriskyTanuki']Of course 2K5 is better than this, it was a third of the price with twice the content. :lol: The flaws in 2K5 that are still around in 2K8 are hard to ignore for the $60 price tag.
Madden has had better controls (the ease of the pre-snap playmaker controls make me cringe when I see that my running back is about to run into a wall of defenders in the 2K games), though I do admit the passing in 2K8 is better than the last Madden game I played (05), but that's too be expected three years later. Madden's players look more like their real counterparts, but at least 2K8 has fat players now instead of seeing a skinny Jerome Bettis rushing for yards in 2K5. The features were pretty much equal, with maybe the online leagues pushing the 2K games ahead of Madden, but that advantage is back in EA's camp now that they have much more to do when you're not online.
With that said, 2K8's a good game, still fun to be had, but it's clearly the first installment of a series with a big potential. If they can meet that potential, great, but right now, this game is only leaving me wanting more.[/quote]
Madden's players look real? Are you serious? Do your research, buddy.
The gamplay is the most important factor, as well as graphics and physics, and APF blows Madden out the water, case closed.