[quote name='wageslave']Thanks for the advice but I'm not planning on doing the yardsale route. I'm tall and will probably need the biggest frame size, want to be selective about what I buy plus I'm doing a little contracting work and have the extra money earmarked for a bike. Money isnt' a huge issue for the purchase and I figure I'll spend the money up front for some quality and be able to enjoy it for a long time.[/quote]
Go to the biggest fanciest Bike store in your area.
Talk to the specialists...where I live many are pro or semi pro riders ....
Note the bike you want and what features are important.
Definitely ride all three tire styles .... RIDE THE BIKE, don't just sit on it...
Now watch craigslist.org (not a garage sale....) or get one at a discounter. I actually bought my cruiser at Wally's...but you really want to get a feel of the bike and need to ride it aroung the block, etc...something the fancy stores will let you do...
Oh, and the fancy stores will be discounting last year's models just now....
For me, tires style, bike weight, shifting style are the most important features....but I have three bikes...touring, mountain and cruiser....