+ Theoretical selection was comparable to Netflix, and even carried some titles Netflix does not (like Star Trek Seasons).
+/- Shipping time was much slower for me than Netflix, but this seems to vary depending on your location.
+ Two free in-store rentals per month. Since this includes games (which rent for $6.99 each right now) this alone is almost worth the price of a subscription.
+ Lower price - $3 a month less than Netflix may not sound like much, but I suppose it adds up after a while.
+ Better return policy - when you report a DVD as missing, damaged, or wrong, they send a replacement right away, even if it means you'll have more than three dvds in your possesion at once. Of course, this also leaves open the possibility of abuse, with people falsely reporting mistakes to speed up delivery times, or receiving more dvds than they should, but it is better than Netflix, which does not send a replacement until they receive the bad disc.
- Waits. Half the dvds I requested on BB had waits on them, while not a single one of the 115+ movies in my queue at Netflix has a wait on it. Also, when there is a wait at Netflix, you ususally receive it within a cycle or two, while short waits at BB only occasionally ship that quickly, and long waits never shipped in my entire 30 day trial, despite being on the top of my list the whole time.
- Wrong dvds. I've only received one wrong dvd at Netflix, and it was a title not even in my queue, and did not count towards my rentals anyway. BB made several mistakes in my trial, especially with different versions of the same movie. For instance, they sent the R rated version of a film several times instead of the unrated or NC-17 title I requested. They also sent Scarface '83 (which I own) instead of Scarface '32, and while these are understandable mistakes, they also totally messed up one request and sent a completely different film.