[quote name='Wolfpup']I liked it okay, but eventually quit playing. Dragon Quest 1 remains the only Dragon Quest game I legitimately like. I like Blue Dragon much, much more.
I disagree about both the 'needing to know Japanese culture/judging it from that perspective', as well as the Lost Odyssey. Final Fantasy 13 is still in my backlog, but aside from it there's nothing this generation that could possibly come close to Lost Odyssey for Japanese RPGs, aside from Blue Dragon, which IMO isn't nearly as good.
And complaining about the characters, calling them shallow and whatnot? Compared to WHAT? Not compared to most games, and certainly not compared to 99% of Japanese RPGs.[/QUOTE]
The problem is, once someone has played Persona 4, every other rpg from then on, particularly in terms of characters, seems relatively terrible. Persona 4 is both a rpg fan's ultimate gift and curse.