CNET recommends on HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray and chooses.....

[quote name='gaelan']audiophile/videophiles will not consider a gaming system as their primary music/video playing device. they will have a kick ass receiver with kick ass speakers and a kick ass standalone dvd/blu ray/hddvd and a kick ass television. basically each component in their system will be dedicated as in no one in all devices such as packaged home theater systems from bestbuy[/QUOTE]

I see this argument a lot, but I really think it's missing the point. I'm planning on getting a PS3 at launch, for the games. However, that will mean I will have a Blu-Ray player as well. So I figure I might as well take advantage of it - I already have my eye on the announced BD Superman collection that's releasing later this year. I know I can't be the only one who feels this way.

This is the area that's going to give Sony the biggest boost - there's only a handful of people (comparatively) that will go out & buy a dedicated player for a new format. But there are quite a few people who will be buying PS3's over the next several years. And if they have the player, they're going to use it.

Also, I see most people when discussing the new formats say something like "I have no interest in replacing my entire collection!" Well...neither do I. But how does that relate exactly? There are a very select few I'd like to see BD versions of in the future (the Pixar films, the LotR extended editions) but for the most part, I'm content with the DVD versions of my movies. However, that doesn't mean that going forward, I won't be buying the BD versions of new movies instead - especially if the price is comperable. It's not like you have to switch formats all-or-nothing. These players WILL still play DVD's, after all, and even if they didn't most people still own DVD players. Your disks aren't going to disintegrate as soon as you bring a new format disk into your house. ;)
 
[quote name='SpazX']AFAIK HD-DVDs will be cheaper to produce and most likely cost less money to the consumer, therefore HD-DVD wins. If it goes the other way I'll be surprised.[/QUOTE]

That missconception is something Sony should have fixed long ago, and could be a big factor in the outcome of this "war".

HD-DVD's will only be cheaper to produce in the short term because modifications to present factories can make manufactoring possible. Blu Ray needs new factories, or completely overhauled ones, to be manufactured. This will be a higher cost at first, but will level out in the long run.

It's like going from coal power plants to nuclear. Sure it's an expensive jump, but in the long run it's worth it because of the better technology involved.
 
I am absolutely surprised that CNET didn't pick Blu-Ray. They are SONY whores! I watched their Tivo download about E3 and it was SONY this and SONY that. And SONY has great games. And SONY has a great new "motion sensitive" controller. Oh, yeah, and Microsoft has some games coming, but nothing worth going into detail. And that other Japanese company, Nintendo, I think? Well, they've got some new system that has a funny name.

Seriously, of the 15 minutes, 1-2 was spent on the Wii, 2-3 was spent on the 360 and 10-12 was on the PS3. There was a long interview with a producer for "Heavenly Sword" that looks like God of War with a chick. And a long demonstration of the new PS3 controller with "Warhawk." The editor went on about how great the controller is, but what they showed on screen looked horribly disconnected between the movement and the plane.

CNET was so pro-SONY, it was disgusting. So, for them to NOT pick Blu-Ray is a shocker indeed.
 
I'll just wait for a player that plays both formats, or for one format to eliminate the other, whichever comes first. I'm in no rush, DVDs will be fine for years to come.
 
bread's done
Back
Top