[quote name='Number83']With this combo, you could get Shin Megami Tensei, Makai Kingdom or Stella Deus and make a killing.[/QUOTE]
This is going to sound like a mtxbass1 post.
Average selling price on eBay (9/17):
Nocturne-$39
Makai Kingdom-$36
Stella Deus-$36
Total-$111
Price at EB games (IF you can find all three at one store):
Nocturne-$0 (It's the cheapest.)
Makai Kingdom-$44.99
Stella Deus-$44.99
Total (after Edge card & 6% sales tax)-$85.86
$111.00-$85.86 is $25.14. Not a bad spread. About 29% profit margin until ...
1. Your games sell $2 less than the average selling price. Now, you're down to 22% profit margin and $19.14 actual profit.
2. You think charging more than $5 for shipping is too much. So, you only charge $4.50. Then, your Paypal/eBay fees are $1.20 for listing each item as a BIN item, $1.60 for a Final Value Fee and $1.46 for Paypal handling the money. Unless you buy padded envelopes in bulk, each envelope will cost you $0.50. Finally, each game's actual postage will be at least $1.52 for USPS first class mail. So, you're losing another $1.78 for each game. Now, you're down to $13.80 profit for the three games or a 16% profit margin.
If somebody is going to resell their B2G1F score on Ebay, I suggest these titles.
Suikdoen IV $17.99 before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $20.
RPG Maker II $17.99 before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $25.
Monster Rancher 4 $24.99 before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $34. WTF?
Suikoden III $27.99 (GS) before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $28.
Zone of the Ender: The 2nd Runner $17.99 before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $24.
Persona 2: Eternal Punishment $29.99 before discount and an Ebay average selling price of $35.
You can charge $4-5 for shipping and cover most of your expenses.
Except for Persona 2, they aren't as rare as Nocturne, Makai Kingdom and Stella Deus. So, their prices won't temporarily dip because of a surge of availability.
Of course, there is something to be said for getting a rare Atlus RPG for little more than some free time invested on Ebay to sell 2 other Atlus RPGs.