[quote name='UncleBob']I agree that, if there's going to be a law, it needs to be concrete with little wiggle room for such vagueness.
It's this particular law that I disagree with.
Again, some people are more coherent at .09 than others are at .07. To give the .07's a free pass while locking up the .09'ers seems silly. Hell, considering the closest I've ever come to drinking is gurgling with Listerine, I'd probably be unable to control a vehicle at .008 - let alone coming anywhere near .08.
Then, you get
this guy, tested with a BAC almost twice what's considered "dead", able to have a coherent conversation. I'd almost bet this guy could drive better at .08 than the majority of people in the Walmart parking lot sober.
As for drinking and driving making "that kind of shit" more likely to happen - *anything* that takes your mind off the road makes that kind of crap more likely to happen. Playing with the radio/MP3 player. Fixing your hair/make-up. Screaming kids in the backseat. Yet, all of these things are perfectly legal - and all of them have lead to fatal car crashes. Should driving while any of these things are happening be illegal?
You're setting a gray line (.08 might be exact, but the amount at which that effects an individual varies - a lot) and saying that anyone who crosses that line is breaking the law because they could potentially be doing something dangerous.[/QUOTE]
1) That's a problem with every law of that type, there are always exceptions, they have to work on averages. It's based on a percentage to take into account differences in body weight, etc. and it's not like they just pulled a random number out of their ass. Also, when you're drunk you're an idiot and don't know at the time how well you can drive.
2) Most of what you're talking about are momentary actions and are also things that some drunk drivers might do while drunk. Fiddling with your radio doesn't impair your reaction times the entire time you're driving, etc. It's also not something you do beforehand and then decide to drive somewhere.