I prefer the Saturn joystick over the Agetec mainly because the joystick spins on the agetec stick and it doesn't on the official saturn one. The buttons are really nice and have a pretty good arcade feel on the agetec one though. I also have that 2 controller in one thing, but it's like having two really cheap agetec joysticks stuck side by side, so unless you and a friend are both 3' 6" and 75lbs, it gets kinda crowded using that one.