[quote name='Kayden']You have to install something like TVersity, but thats really no different than how you have to have media center (or the extender) installed and running. It also lets me play quicktime, real media, xvid, mkv, vob or just about any other codec/container.[/quote]
Ah now I see the confusion. Tversity is a transcoder (which works just as easily with the 360) which means your PC does all the work of converting, in near real time, to a format the PS3/360 likes. I have never had good luck with it, as it degrades quality, unless you have a super powered PC.
There is a huge difference with Media Center/Media Extender. All those do is send the file over your LAN to your xbox and your xbox does all the work. So in other words, there is no conversion going on. It will look the same on the xbox as it will watching your PC - not to mention your PC's CPU isn't pegged trying to covert video on the fly, so it's still usable. Windows Media Center/Extender essentially make your PC a portable hard drive for the 360, wherever it is on the network. That's it.
If you're idea of crappy cables is stock, then yea, I'm using Microsoft's component cables that come with the pros. On the PS3 I'm using HDMI with a DVI adapter. If its a connection issue, then the PS3 should actually look worse because of the adapter. (You lose signal fidelity every time there is a change in medium.)
No idea then. I'm one of those guys that researches for months before buying a piece of AV equipment. My ps3 is HDMI and my 360 is VGA, and I see no difference in playing games.
You certainly would notice a difference with regular DVD though, as the 360's scaler isn't "allowed" to work except through VGA/HDMI, as mandated by the DVD Forum. In other words - regular DVD over component on the 360 looks gawd awful.
Using the same videos from the same computer to the same tv, the PS3 is noticeably sharper when upscaling the image. The image can get blurry on the edges and there are more artifacts. The PS3 is markedly better. I find the same to be true with DVDs.
I'm still confused about what upscaling of videos your ps3 is doing other than with DVD. If you are using Tversity, and telling it to upscale, then Tversity is doing the upscaling, and would/should look exactly the same no matter what Tversity was sending it to.
For the games, I think PS2 games are upscaled better on the PS3 than xbox games are on the 360.
You got me there. I don't play either on either console, so I wouldn't know.
My TV is only 1080i, so HDMI vs component really shouldn't make any difference. The 360 games look good, but anything I upscale doesn't. I'm not going to go out and buy a new 360 either.
Right. You really shouldn't notice a difference with games, that's where I was confused (except for BC games). If your 360 were connected by VGA/HDMI then DVD's would look closer to the PS3 quality, but that's not necessary for your set up.