Well, the more I think about it, the more upset I get. It seems like false advertising. Had I bought 2, the price would have been $6 less than what I paid, so it is not buy 2 get one free, it is buy 2 for more than you would ordinarily have to pay, get one free. It would be slightly different (i.e. I would be griping less) if they didn't have stickers on every game that say "MVP Price: $xx.xx". Those stickers imply that that is the normal price for members, and any "event" discount should therefore be taken from that price. I will be writing an email, and possibly a letter, to GameCrazy (no, I won't be mentioning CAG), but I don't really expect anything to come of it.