[quote name='magilacudy']None of my friends were gamers so I was pretty much the only one anticipating Halo 2. That all changed once I got them to play through the original.[/quote]
I'm not really sure that counts. You may have been the only one of your friends anticipating it, but obviously many other people were also looking forward to it.
I'm not even sure Katamari Damacy should count since so many people on here wanted it in advance, although it was largely ignored by the mainstream. Most of the games that I want that nobody else seems to care about end up as vapor or import-only. I was really looking forward to Rent-A-Hero No. 1 for Dreamcast, and the Dungeons and Dragons games for Saturn.
I was hoping that the most recent Leisure Suit Larry wouldn't destroy the series, I pre-ordered it, it sucked. I don't have the greatest track record for these things.
I am looking forward to Chulip as well.
7th Guest was 100 times better than Myst, imho.