[quote name='SAGExSDX']what i dont like are the people using this deal to cash in on other games... something just doesn't seem right about that. the deal is to trade in 3 gba games for nintendogs... not 3 gba games for $30 credit... ah well.[/QUOTE]
Wow, this thread has gotten very interesting with all these ethical debates.
1) How private or public should our community be
2) Is it OK to take advantage of faults in a major bureaucratic institution
On Manimal's offense, I don't have much to say . . . better to keep our community tight and small but some of his "converts" (people who become involved because they find out about CAG could be major contributors).
On the question of "flipping" I'm pretty interested. I'm a major flipper . . . if I can buy a $5 game (esp. if there is more than one copy) and get $10 (in credit because most of the preorder games . . . say, Madden . . . don't interest me) I will do it. Oddly, I love EB so much because I hate EB so much. Personally, I think they ripoff most of their customers and the customers do trades because can't do any better.
But this isn't the only part to my trades. Mostly, I don't feel bad because I feel I'm getting a finder's fee by turning in non-PO games that are in new condition at my local store. When I took a $5 Siren and got $11.33 for it, I was adding that game to the shelf and someone with EB credit could buy it . . . I increased the selection. I didn't get $10 in cash . . . I got a committment to spend $10 at EB which actually increases their volume.
Where it gets tricker and murkier ethically is when one flips games directly at the store itself. So, you buy a $5 game and then trade it in for $10 in credit and buy the $5 game and then trade it in for credit . . . this crosses an ethical line even for me
Alot of instore flipping will bring the deal crashing to a halt (for everyone). This appears to be what happened with the PSP game deal . . . but we had pretty good info that it was employees themselves who really exploited it.
PLUS: the OP's story (honestly hope it works out for him) sounds like it could be a TV movie . . .
![Shaq Fu! fuck fuck](/styles/default/cag/smilies/shaq-fu!96.gif)
EB if they get down on him for posting here.