[quote name='Squarehard']Unfortunately with all of the previous Hastings sale, all of these things you are saying about the quality vary way too much with every person. I would say about 50% of the people who do these sales come out with complete games, and the other come out with just awful quality games. I am normally always the one posting these deals in the past, but in all 3 of the threads, it just spans on page after page of people getting poor quality games and some people have absolutely no problem (myself included). So its all good and done to give a full description on the quality, but its better just to let everyone know what has happened in the past with everyone else instead of just your own personal experience. Like I said, I have no problem with them, but many do apparently T___T
[/QUOTE]
Maybe we should try compiling a tally from the past couple threads to get a good sense of the success (or failure) rate.
+ I bought 6 games, all current-gen (including DS) and all complete and good condition
From the last thread:
Related to the condition of used games:
- addicted2games - scratched, incomplete older PS2 games
+ dcm1602 - older ps3 games, like new condition
+ bvharris - older ps2 games in near-perfect condition
+ yokissmybass - immaculate blu-rays
- bruceg - kept less than 1/2 last-gen games; few were incomplete, but many were heavily scratched
+ bvharris - 3 PS2 games in good condition
+ kaskd - ordered 3 games, received 2 in good condition but never received 3rd
+ Squarehard - 18 DS games, all complete and good condition
- Bhhawks78 - 2 games in generic cases/no manuals and terrible/unplayable condition
+ fyrflash1969 - 2 current-gen games in complete, good condition
+ xycury - All DS were complete. 1 of 9 PSP games came without a manual but had original casing.
+ aeri - 2 PS2, 1 PSP game in complete condition, though cases were less than ideal.
+ ryemm - 6 games, 5 mint and 1 near-mint.
Also, posted by The Lone Pig: "I have had more luck with used games coming complete over pre-played. They're usually cheaper too for some reason."
Related to goHastings' customer service:
- sadikyo - problem with shipping and getting over 10 "new" games as used
- cheapndirty - similar problem
- tomfool - received an audio CD instead of a PS3 game; sent back CD but item never arrived and goHastings refuses to send him the game
- kaskd - ordered 3 games, received 2 in good condition but never received 3rd
- freshzen - canceled order
- rickshankshaw - canceled order
- michael90002002 - one game came 3 weeks later and wasn't even the correct one
The sample size is fairly small and is by no means conclusive nor is it comprehensive, but so far it seems most people have had no problems. The complaints people had had less to do with the condition of games and more with bad orders and customer service. Also, keep in mind that people who got the wrong end of the stick tend to be more vocal than people who got what they want (which is the expectation).