I love scare games, but its been a long time since I got some good chills. And I can't think of any recent ones that were scary, but being a kid these two scared me many times.
1. Alone in the Dark
2. Friday the 13th
3.??
SH1, was ok as far as scares, res evil 2?.... I beat that game in one sitting and killed the last boss with a knife. I don't find any of the res evil games scary, but only played the old psx/dc ones and 4 on gc.
I really want to try, Fatal Frame, Clock Tower, System Shock, The Suffering. It's also nice that on some of these older games the graphics are so bad, I wonder how it was shocking in the first place,,, res evil 1 psx... the acting is scary