[quote name='DrFoo']I just paid $450 for a HP laptop PC with a 1.7 ghz dual core athlon cpu, 1 gb ram (found a deal for 2 gb for $35 to help with games), a 5400 rpm 160 gb hard drive, and a 15.4 inch widescreen monitor. It boots up quickly, can do everything you would want to do on a mac, and can play most modern games. I have had no problems with it at all, and yes it has Vista. Unless its worth $500 to lose a little weight (mine is 6 pounds) and have a build in webcam, a Mac is a terrible idea. They are completely over rated and over priced (considering the minimum cost for a macbook is $1100...).
Oh and just looking it up, that $1100 mac has a 13" screen, 1 GB ram, and an 80 gb hard drive. In other words, its a piece of shit. Its CPU is a little faster, but what are you going to use that for on a Mac?[/QUOTE]
With all due respect, you seem to be rather biased in this regard.
First of all, the $1100 Mac is actually a $1,000 Mac after student discount.
Second, I was 99.9% sure that the mac book was lighter before finishing your post, which is a HUGE issue. Light laptops cost more. Most 4lb laptops start around $600 when you get a good deal, and average price is $800 - $1,200. That alone makes such a huge difference. As I said, my 7lb Toshiba was far too heavy for me to consider truly 'mobile'. I could not just throw it in my backpack without taking something else out to keep the weight bearable.
Third, the lowest end MacBook is much faster than your PC. Not only is a much faster processor, but OSX is much more efficient. The MacBook is faster, but even if it wasn't, with equal hardware the Mac would be faster.
Fourth, you list 13" screen as a negative thing... it isn't. It keeps it light. The MacBook's screen is likely much higher quality than yours. The new LED screens have incredible brightness and contrast, and I bet the 13" is the same resolution as your 15", resulting in a higher pixel density which creates a sharper image.
Fifth, since your laptop has Vista at that price, how long have you had it? Two months, tops? It's not fair to say you haven't had any problems with it. That's not a point you're yet fit to make. I bet in the course of 3 years you do have issues. I would, honest to god, place money down on a bet in favor of you having technical issues with that $450 laptop within 3 years. I would not be comfortable placing the same bet against a Mac. That's based on my 3 years of experience as a ERT at Staples (think Geek Squad, except paid less).
As I said, I don't own a Mac and I never have... MacBooks are just great products at a good price. I would not be recommending a Mac if the OP were looking for a desktop... but for a laptop, definitely.