I've been pretty lucky with my buys off eBay, until now. A week ago I bought a game that was listed as having a *MINT* disc, but today I found that it's nowhere near mint. The disc is covered in circular scratches (refinishing, I'm sure) and has an 1x1inch section covered with over twenty 1/16th inch scratches. It looks horrible.
Mint my ass.
So, do I simply open up a dispute in Paypal? Is there anything I can do to help my case?

So, do I simply open up a dispute in Paypal? Is there anything I can do to help my case?