Help shopping for MP3 player (iPod? Zune?)

SilverPaw750

CAGiversary!
Feedback
35 (100%)
I've noticed lately that my car is drowning in CD's, so I think it's about time I bite the bullet and get myself in touch with some actual technology, i.e. an MP3 player.

Anyways, there are four probably options, and I have a few questions about each - anyone who owns one of these babies or knows about them, I'd appreciate the help!

iPod Classic 80GB
I was certain I was going to stick with the Classic, but there are a couple things that concern me about it. First of all, all of the display models I've tested out in stores have extremely unresponsive click wheels, especially compared to my sister's 5G iPod. I've heard there's a software update that may address this issue...any comments? Also, is it true that once the Classic goes idle after thirty seconds or so that it stops displaying what song is playing and switches to a battery/clock view? That seems like a pretty big step back.

iPod Touch 16GB
More expensive, yes, and less space, but damn if it's not a sweet piece of technology. I find navigating music the easiest on the Touch. It's 16GB, but what's the formatted capacity? I already have 13.2 GB of music, but a whopping 5.3 GB of that are Video Game Soundtracks, very few of which I'd need to have stored on my iPod for convenient listening (I really don't need all 7 Metal Slug soundtracks with me at all times). If I got a touch, would I be able to deselect a lot of the game music? Also, around what time of the year does Apple announce it's annual new iPod models? I may want to wait for a 32GB touch...

Zune 80
This is actually my favorite MP3 player of the bunch, and it seemed the most intuitive and easy to use from my hands on time. Problem is, all of my music is already organized in iTunes, and I've heard some terrible things about the Zune software. Apparently it'll auto transfer over all of the music except those purchased from iTunes, but I can just burn and reimport the seven or so CD's worth of music I've purchased from iTunes. Still, is the Zune software as horrendous as I've heard? iTunes is pretty damn great...

iPod 5G
All of these options have their downfalls, so I've considered getting an older iPod for cheap, but I'm wary of buying a used or refurbished model...my sister bought one and has had quite a few problems with it in around a year's time.


I've looked around at some other options, but I want it mainly for music (so Archos is a bit much), and I really dislike the Creative Zen players.

Anyone have any advice or other recommendations?

Thanks! :bouncy:
 
I have an Ipod touch it lets you choose to add all songs or only the ones you checked off. I like the wifi on the touch to check email and kill time on youtube,(youporn doesnt work with out a plug in). I dont have alot of music so 16 is fine for me, I have a few movies on there.
 
I bought a 30g zune (1st gen) and I loved it until the new software came out. Then I hated it. It's really slow and it's really hard to deleted/add files, so I returned it to BestBuy (thank you Product Replacement Plan) and exchanged a iPod Touch.
 
[quote name='sasukekun']I bought a 30g zune (1st gen) and I loved it until the new software came out. Then I hated it. It's really slow and it's really hard to deleted/add files, so I returned it to BestBuy (thank you Product Replacement Plan) and exchanged a iPod Touch.[/QUOTE]

Really? On my 30GB it sped it up tremendously. Id say to the OP the 30GB Zune is a great deal, since you can find it for 100$ or so online.

Edit: wait, I guess you mean the PC software. Yeah, it's pretty icky. I just use it to transfer and thats it.
 
[quote name='VipFREAK']Pains me to say it... get a Touch.

BTW, It's a great PDA.[/QUOTE]
Haha... That's exactly the reason I bought it :D

Plus the touch feature is cool! I only got an 8g, I have 25 gigs of music, but I only listen to about a gigs worth.
 
get a zune 80 not only does it have the biggest screen of the hard drive models but it has wireless sync capabilities.
 
[quote name='sasukekun']Haha... That's exactly the reason I bought it :D

Plus the touch feature is cool! I only got an 8g, I have 25 gigs of music, but I only listen to about a gigs worth.[/quote]

I had a 5g video which was excusively used as a video player and loved it. I then got an Archos 704 and haven't looked back. No converting ftw!

I got the 16gb touch strictly as a PDA and portable internet device. I have music and video podcasts but it's not the primary functions. Hell I listen to Streaming Radio off it more than the music I got on it. xD

As for my music collection all 60gb or so went down the drain with the rest of my data in a hard drive error... bummed about that. Luckily my best friend has an even more massive collection than I did.
 
+1 for the touch

i got mine new off craigslist for pretty damn cheap and it's been great (whenever the girlfriend doesn't steal it)
 
I have the Classic and really like it. Haven't had much experience with the touch but it sounds like it's a worthwhile step up if you can afford the space limits.
 
you don't have to burn all of your itunes songs then import!!
Use myfairtunes to take off the DRM without any loss in quality.
 
bread's done
Back
Top