[quote name='mykevermin']I'm not trying to argue science, but rather, that the concept of 'bruising' isn't all that complex. Simply put, shaking a shaker (sounds redundant, no?) chips the ice. When the drink is poured into the glass, the ice can (and does) fall into the drink with the liquor.
Ultimately, the question is "what is the necessary amount of ice chips to noticably dilute the flavor?" Well, a solid vodka has very little flavor to begin with, so choosing any vodka makes it a different equation than gin from the get-go. It's not "can a vodka martini be bruised?" because we all know that it's physically possible (and frequently occurring) that bruised vodkas are served. That's a *fact.* Only the most refined of palates (i.e., not mine) could really tell if the flavor of the drink is off (and even then, other factors, from the temperature of the glass, the kind of vodka itself, the amount/type of vermouth, and granishes, make it a far more difficult equation to begin with). When I was a bartender, I would always stir, and shake when asked. Why? Because people are often picky but not very knowledgable, and nobody's ever returned a martini because it wasn't bruised.
In the end, if it's up to me, I'll have a Jameson on the rocks with a splash of water and a squeeze of lemon; nevertheless, this topic was about martinis, so rather than tell you about my preferred bourbons (not many) or about the hop flavor I adore in an IPA, I said what kind of martini I liked. So I said that, and somehow my preference became a point of contention with some prat (not you) who wanted to question my taste, as if he has a better grasp on it than I do. Jaysis.
Can't say I've ever heard of "golden ears," however. I sure don't have them, whatever they are.[/QUOTE]Yeah, I'm fine with temp and dilution changing the flavor of a drink. But there are people who argue that the actual act of shaking is what causes the change in flavor. Like kinetic energy tastes like something.
Anyway, I'm a single malt drinker, so I prefer Scotch, to the horror of my ancestry (though, Bushmills is fine enough.) And golden ears are the people who buy into audio cables that cost in the tens of thousands of dollars because they think they can hear static otherwise.