[quote name='meteors'][quote name='scsg75'][quote name='meteors']EB is selling them, but they were given away from Nintendo for free. They're the true crooks IMHO.[/quote]
For free, yeah, if you meet certain criteria, ie: regestering games, subscription etc. They did not give them away as part of the promotion if you wrote them lying saying they never shipped out a copy, which they did, and he subsquently sold to to a gamestore for profit. Your point makes no sense.[/quote]
The disc is a FREE gift. You have to qualify by getting other Nintendo products but it's still a promotional gift.
Calling somebody and lying is not a promotion. Your point makes no sense, I'm not even sure what you're trying to call me out on. I don't defend this guy for scamming a disc, but I do think the guys tattling are lame.
Obviously Nintendo doesn't value them very much if they'll just send one out to somebody who calls and complains. You can't do that for a regular game.... probably only FREE ones.

[/quote]
Dude, Your point I believe was that Nintendo was giving them away for free.
My point was yes for free after meeting certain criteria.
My point was the criteria in the promotion did not include writing them a letter lying to them to get it for free, which this kid did.
Your original point was that Nintendo gave them away for free anyway, so no one really loses, which makes no sense because there were certain ways to get the disc for free all geared to promote and generate sales of other Nintendo products (games, subscriptions, systems) and lying was not one of them.
I'm not sure why this is so confusing for you