The closest Gamecrazy had two complete copies of ICO for $18 or so a few months back, but it was in the ghetto. You might want to try your local ghetto-neighborhood gamestore. I doubt many people would look for a game like ICO in stores like those.
They are pretty reliable, but I have never bought anything USED from them so be carefull and hope you get a box and manual...[/QUOTE]
Their used quality is just under Gamefly's IMO. I just bought Psychonauts, and aside from a few slight scuffs (obvious play wear), the condition of the case/manual/game was flawless. Their prices suck sometimes, but 14.99 for Ico definitely ain't bad.