If he still has the packaging then I think most places will take it back. I've taken a logitech one back to Gamestop before because it couldn't do motion sensing for whatever reason.
[quote name='mtxbass1']Target changed their return policy such that they don't allow any return without a receipt. How were you able to get around this company wide policy?[/quote]
Funny you should mention that. I was stuck in the return line at target the other night, someone couldn't find their receipt and the exasperated clerk said that if they had the card they had purchased it with that would work. Things went south from their since the person had like 20+ credit cards. Some one else was called over and they said if the item was under $20 they'd take it back no questions asked.
Let me get to the real question.. I somehow broke my Sixaxis and want to buy a new one at Target and return my broken one... would they be able to tell if I did that?