[quote name='epobirs']I wouldn't make the comparison to Sam Raimi. Raimi spent most of his career training to make something like Spider-man while Smith has done best in genres that have never been box office gold but do well over time in second run venue and home video. Smith doesn't have the directorial eye for big money epics and shouldn't bother himself with them. For Smith to be succesful at something like his hoped-for Superman project he'd need to give almost equal billing to the Production Designer.[/quote]
I had just written a more indepth comparison now to reply to this, but then changed my mind. You probably are more correct, for most intents and purposes. I will more shortly say that Raimi was not trying to make mainstream films for the first 10 years of career, Evil Dead trilogy and work for the Coen Brothers pretty clearly obviates that, and that his string of attemped mainstream hits (The Gift, A Simple Plan) and misses (For the Love of the Game, Quick and the Dead) as well as his generally well-recieved treatment of the Spiderman films show that he has earned his way to the top and his talent still shows. Smith on the other hand has just rounded out his 10th year as a filmmaker, pretty early by comparison.
I'll admit I'm probably being a little unfair to Jersey Girl. I couldn't bring myself to see it in theaters. By most accounts, both on the internet, critical reviews, and first-hand accounts from people I knew who did see it, the movie is a failure. I fear seeing it.
I totally agree that Smith should have nothing to do with big money epics. Your statement on the Superman project is an apt one. His messed up jump from Clerks to Mallrats (a funny movie with good scenes in retrospect, if not for the misguided casting of the main stars, general waste of budget, and lack of good cohesiveness) was seemingly cleared up with Dogma and JSBSB.
I still think he's better off persuing something new (this Green Hornet screenplay), finishing up one of his two dropped off comic book miniseries. Like you said, if Jersey Girl wasn't a huge bomb, and Miramax is obviously cashing in on Clerks X (*Groan*) he probably still has enough leeway to try something else.