[quote name='bojay1997']Very rarely has this happened with New Egg and it has always been somewhat older games. I'd rather spend a few extra dollars for something brand new rather than a former rental.[/QUOTE]
While this may be true, I've actually been surprised at the quality of the GameFly pre-owned discs I've been sent too. I ordered HAWX off of there and it was like-new, no scratches, perfect and intact case with all included paperwork (but thats possibly due to no one renting it since the game sucked.. but I wouldn't think KoF would be much different in the US).
Most surprisingly, it came in similar condition to the "new" Armored Core: For Answer I had ordered from NewEgg -- which came in terrible packaging and had the cover quite crushed.
Then again, I'm also a CAG and this is just my experience.