Wow so many over-hyped games. Ones that come straight to mind are Enter the Matrix and Halo. Enter the matrix was hyped along with the movies and when it came out it turned into one of the worst games ever developed with all the glitches it had. And to think that that game had so much potential if they hadn't put it out that early and had worked out the kinks of it.
Halo is an over hyped game because at the time that I bought it everyone was like oh it is the funnest FPS ever and it kills Goldeneye, etc. not to mention that to me it was the only o.k. looking game at the time for XBox. when I played it, it turned out to be a very average at best FPS. It was like a used car, shiny and nice looking on the exterior, but in the inside with lacked depth and it was a car without substance. The stroy was an average sci-fi story at best that mimicked many others (and which now other sci-fi FPS's have been mimicking this mimicker), the level design was extremely linear, and the famed cars had some of the worst controls ever. the music was good in it and A.I. was quite challenging on the harder difficulties, but other than that it wasn't that great like everybody proclaimed it was.