I'm glad you all responded AFTER I saw a lack of response and changed my mind. 'At least 50 cents' includes 'more than 50 cents'. I was checking values, and a few of the games would actually get like 5-8 from that store. That's definitely more than I'd get here.
I'm probably not going to take everything over for a couple of weeks, but as I said, I'm more interested in number of bids rather than net value. Since I doubt I'd get a blanket bid of $1 on everything, I made the call that not enough bids would be made to make it worth my time. I've held lowballs before, I know the time investment.