[quote name='ragtop70']If you want Ico to be art, fine. Find the most beautiful scene in the game and pause it. How long are you going to leave that image on your screen before you get bored with your art? Sooner or later you're going to put a GAME in your PS2 GAME console and play that GAME. I've said it before in other topics, Ico was marketed as a game, not as artwork. If it had been sold as art, I never would have bought. I have nothing against art, but I was taking the word of my fellow CAGers that this is a great, underrated GAME.[/QUOTE]
It's cute how you didn't seem to follow what I said at all. There are all different kinds of art; it can just as much be an experience as it can be a still-frame, or a sculpture, or any sort of creative form of expression that you (okay, maybe not you particularly, seeing as you've had such a difficult time wrapping your brain around things thus far) can imagine.. You also don't seem to understand that, just because you didn't appreciate Ico because it wasn't what you were looking for, that doesn't make it any less of an enjoyable experience for other people who've played it, or any less a game. Not only was it a game, but it was a damn fun, and *damn pretty* game.
[quote name='ragtop70']The reason I'm stating my opinion so boldly is because it would appear to onlookers that Ico (and most likely Shadow) are undisputably excellent games. I'm sure there are just as many people who hate the game as there are who love it.[/QUOTE]
Find me these numbers and I'll let it go, but right now you're just pulling fictional statistics out of your ass to support your non-arguement.
[quote name='ragtop70']Finally, I would never have even checked out this thread if it hadn't been on the front page. I don't go looking for Ico topics to crap in, though I have crapped on Ico before.[/QUOTE]
It's all well and good that you don't like the game, and there's nothing wrong with constructively sharing your opinion on it so that those looking to purchase either Shadow of the Colossus or Ico can make an informed decision for themselves, but you seem to have avoided every opportunity at tactfully presenting your point of view. Congratulations on looking like a fool.
... And until you actually play Shadow of the Colossus, I don't see what relevance *any* of your Ico-bashing has to this thread. If you've already "said it before" about Ico in other threads, as you stated, certainly your redundancy is not necessary.